Television Review: The Icarus Factor (Star Trek: The Next Generation, S2X14, 1989)

The Icarus Factor (S02E14)

Airdate: April 24th 1989

Written by: David Assael & Robert L. McCollough
Directed by: Robert Iscove

Running Time: 45 minutes

Star Trek: The Next Generation, in its ambitious seven-year voyage, possessed the narrative luxury afforded to long-running episodic science fiction: the capacity to occasionally step away from the relentless pressure of universe-threatening crises or high-stakes ethical dilemmas. Episodes could, theoretically, embrace a quieter, more introspective "slice of life" approach, focusing on intricate worldbuilding or deep character exposition for the crew of the USS Enterprise-D. Such deviations, when executed with skill, could enrich the series' tapestry, demonstrating that life aboard a starship, even one exploring strange new worlds, was also composed of mundane transfers, personal reckonings, and the quiet hum of routine. Season 2’s The Icarus Factor (Episode 14) explicitly positions itself within this category, promising a character-driven exploration of familial discord. Yet, tragically, it represents not a successful experiment in quiet storytelling, but a profound misfire; the creators swung so wildly away from the series' established strengths that they landed not in nuanced drama, but in the barren, dramatically inert territory of uninspired soap opera, utterly devoid of compelling action, genuine pathos, or even the saving grace of wit.

The plot ostensibly hinges on Commander William Riker receiving a pivotal career opportunity: command of the USS Aries, tasked with pioneering exploration in the Vega-Omicron sector. Before accepting, he must consult with a civilian advisor assigned to the mission. This advisor, arriving at Starbase Montgomery, is revealed to be none other than Kyle Riker (Mitchell Ryan), Will’s estranged father, from whom he has been completely cut off for nearly fifteen years. Kyle, seemingly remorseful, attempts a tentative reconciliation, burdened by the weight of past failures as a parent. However, this fragile overture is complicated by the revelation that Kyle once shared a passionate romantic entanglement with the Enterprise's Chief Medical Officer, Dr. Katherine Pulaski. Will, harbouring deep resentment, initially rebuffs his father’s advances. Their simmering tension culminates in a ritualistic Anbo-jytsu match – a Riker family tradition where Kyle historically dominated. Mid-fight, Kyle confesses to cheating in their past contests, a moment of vulnerability that finally cracks Will’s defences, leading to a swift, almost bewilderingly abrupt reconciliation. Kyle departs, and despite Captain Picard’s strong encouragement to seize command of the Aries, Will elects to remain as First Officer aboard the Enterprise. Concurrently, Worf grapples with the tenth anniversary of his Klingon Rite of Ascension, feeling isolated without his people; Geordi, Data, and friends provide holodeck reconstruction of the ritual to honour him.

On paper, the script by David Assael and Robert L. McCollough attempts a worthy goal: grounding TNG in relatable human (and Klingon) experience. It posits that Starfleet life isn't solely about photon torpedoes and alien negotiations; it’s also about personnel transfers, unresolved family baggage, and cultural milestones celebrated in solitude. This focus on the "banal" could have been a strength, showcasing the series' depth beyond its sci-fi trappings. The problem lies not in the intent to depict everyday life, but in the execution of the chosen everyday drama. Will Riker’s profound, decade-and-a-half-long estrangement from his father is clumsily, almost insultingly, interwoven with his career dilemma. The script fails utterly to establish a credible internal struggle for Will regarding the Aries command. Is the Enterprise truly a "more prominent ship"? Undoubtedly, but the script never articulates why staying is the right choice for him beyond vague loyalty. The arguments Picard offers are perfunctory, and Riker’s ultimate decision feels entirely preordained by the show’s structure – Jonathan Frakes was far too central to the cast for his departure to be viable long-term, rendering the entire command dilemma a hollow narrative cul-de-sac from the outset. Furthermore, the contrivance of Kyle Riker, of all people in the vast Federation, being Pulaski’s former lover is a credibility-stretching coincidence that feels far more implausible than any warp-core breach or temporal anomaly the series regularly dealt with. It reeks of lazy plotting, sacrificing believability for a cheap, unearned emotional complication.

The resolution of the central father-son conflict is equally unconvincing and dramatically unsatisfying. Their decades of bitterness are supposedly dissolved not through meaningful dialogue or a gradual rebuilding of trust, but via a confession of cheating during a laughably staged martial arts contest. The Anbo-jytsu sequence, intended as a moment of high tension and symbolic significance, instead resembles a poorly choreographed parody of American Gladiators – all padding, awkward stances, and a distinct lack of martial authenticity. It transforms a potentially powerful cathartic moment into unintentional comedy, undermining the gravity the scene desperately needed. Mitchell Ryan, a formidable actor capable of immense presence (as evidenced by his iconic role as General McAllister in Lethal Weapon), is utterly wasted. His Kyle Riker oscillates between gruff regret and sudden, unearned warmth without sufficient psychological grounding, leaving his character feeling shallow and his redemption unearned. The reconciliation feels imposed by the script’s need for a tidy ending, devoid of the messy, hard-won catharsis such a rift would realistically demand.

The Worf subplot, while technically proficient in its depiction of Klingon ritual and the crew’s earnest effort, suffers from being pure, uninspired filler. It lacks thematic connection to the main plot beyond a superficial "characters have personal issues" parallel. Geordi and Data’s holodeck reconstruction, though visually interesting, feels like an obligatory nod to Worf’s culture rather than a meaningful exploration of his isolation or Klingon identity, ultimately adding little substance to the episode’s core failure.

Consequently, The Icarus Factor stands as a notable misstep in TNG's otherwise robust early development. It is rarely cited among the series’ memorable or beloved episodes, its reputation tarnished by its fundamental dramatic shortcomings. Even within the production itself, opinions were starkly divided, reflecting the episode’s inherent flaws. Jonathan Frakes, naturally, appreciated the rare deep dive into Riker’s backstory. Conversely, Sir Patrick Stewart reportedly expressed significant displeasure upon initially reading the script, intuitively recognising its weak foundation. Director Robert Iscove later publicly blamed Gene Roddenberry’s influence claiming it prevented him from injecting the necessary raw emotion and complexity the story required, leaving it stranded in tepid melodrama. This internal conflict underscores the episode’s core problem: it aspired to emotional depth but was crippled by poor plotting, unconvincing character motivations, and a resolution that felt less like earned drama and more like a hastily scribbled script note demanding "fix family issue here."

While TNG was right to explore quieter character moments, The Icarus Factor proves that merely avoiding phasers and planet-killers is insufficient. True character drama demands compelling internal conflicts, believable motivations, and resolutions earned through genuine struggle – not contrived coincidences, perfunctory martial arts confessions, or career dilemmas rendered meaningless by the show’s own structural realities.

RATING: 4/10 (+)

Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo

LeoDex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e

BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9