Television Review: The Winds of Winter (Game of Thrones, S6X10, 2016)

The Winds of Winter (S6x10)

Airdate: 26 June 2016

Written by: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
Directed by: Miguel Sapochnik

Running Time: 68 minutes

The world of George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire is so elaborately constructed, its political and mystical plots so densely interwoven, that the process of simplifying its narrative for a television audience became the central, Herculean challenge of Game of Thrones’ later seasons. This distillation, moving from a sprawling, multi-focal chronicle towards a more streamlined, climactic confrontation, required not just narrative compression but significant temporal space. It is within this context that the Season 6 finale, The Winds of Winter, must be viewed. Its extended runtime—one of the series’ longest episodes—is less a luxury and more a necessity, a final, sprawling canvas upon which showrunners David Benioff and D.B. Weiss could attempt to tidy the vast board, resolve lingering threads, and launch the endgame. Yet, as this episode demonstrates, the act of ‘mopping up’ a story of such initial richness often sacrifices thematic depth and logical consistency for the sake of visceral impact and plot propulsion.

Following the established pattern of the show’s seasonal rhythms, Winds of Winter functions as a monumental narrative mop-up in the wake of the prior episode’s ‘wham’ moment—the cathartic, mud-and-blood victory of Jon Snow over Ramsay Bolton at the Battle of the Bastards, which restored Stark dominion over Winterfell. However, Benioff and Weiss subvert their own formula by inserting a second, almost equally consequential ‘wham’ event within this finale, fundamentally reshaping the political landscape in a single, fiery stroke. This dual function—resolving one major conflict while explosively igniting another—creates a structurally lopsided but undeniably potent piece of television, one that simultaneously represents the apex of the show’s cinematic spectacle and a telling milestone in its gradual departure from the nuanced, cause-and-effect storytelling that defined its early years.

The episode’s masterstroke, and its undeniable centre of gravity, is the destruction of the Great Sept of Baelor. The sequence begins with Cersei Lannister in a position of apparent desperation. Cornered by the High Sparrow’s zealous regime, a very public trial for her alleged sins (and those of Loras Tyrell) is set to commence. Her defiance in refusing to attend, and her deployment of the zombified Mountain to prevent her son, King Tommen, from doing the same, initially reads as the last, stubborn stand of a wounded lioness. The trial itself unfolds with a grim predictability that masterfully builds dread. Loras Tyrell, psychologically shattered by his captivity, publicly confesses, renounces his titles, and submits to the Faith’s branding, his humiliation etching despair onto the faces of his father, Mace, and sister, Margaery. It is Natalie Dormer’s performance as Margaery that provides the sequence’s crucial pivot. Her character’s sharp political instincts cut through the religious fervour; noting Cersei’s absence, she correctly intuits that such blatant defiance signals a catastrophic plan. Her urgent plea to evacuate the sept is tragically ignored by the arrogantly assured High Sparrow, an error that seals the fate of everyone within.

The revelation of Cersei’s plan, orchestrated by the sinister Qyburn—who concurrently dispatches his old rival Grand Maester Pycelle via a murder of ‘little birds’—is a masterpiece of suspenseful cross-cutting. As the devout Lancel Lannister pursues a mysterious child into the catacombs beneath the city, the audience is shown the horrifying payload: vast stockpiles of the volatile wildfire, strategically placed. The imagery of carefully positioned candles dripping wax towards the barrels is pure Hitchcockian tension. Lancel’s discovery comes too late; a blade to the spine leaves him paralysed, forced to watch helplessly as the green flame ignites. What follows is an act of deicidal annihilation. The subsequent detonation is a triumph of special effects, a horrifyingly beautiful bloom of emerald fire that consumes High Sparrow, Mace, Loras, and Margaery Tyrell, alongside hundreds of septons, nobles, and smallfolk. The physical and symbolic heart of the Faith of the Seven is obliterated, and with it, the primary structures of moral and political opposition to Cersei in the capital.

The scene’s power is magnified by exceptional direction from Miguel Sapochnik, who understands that the true horror lies in the anticipation and the intimate human reactions amidst the grandeur. The performances from the condemned—particularly Jonathan Pryce’s suddenly fearful High Sparrow and Natalie Dormer’s frantic, intelligent Margaery—lend gravitas to their characters’ abrupt ends. The historical echo of the Gunpowder Plot is apt, though here the plotter succeeds with apocalyptic finality. However, the sequence is not without its missteps. Ramin Djawadi’s piano-led ‘Light of the Seven’ score, while ambitious, tips dangerously into melodrama, its repetitive, tinkling notes arguably over-signalling impending doom rather than complementing it. Furthermore, by placing this cataclysmic event so early in the episode’s runtime, it inadvertently casts a pall over the subsequent scenes, many of which feel like necessary but attenuated footnotes in comparison.

Cersei’s triumph, however, is instantly rendered pyrrhic. In a chilling coda, she confronts Septa Unella (Hannah Waddingham), her former tormentor. Lena Headey’s performance here is a masterclass in vindictive, unhinged glee. Gloating, she mockingly offers Unella wine (“Shame! Shame! Shame!”) before confessing her own wickedness with terrifying relish and departing, leaving the Mountain to enact a slow, implied torture. This personal vengeance is hollowed out by the subsequent, quieter tragedy. Her son Tommen, witnessing the smoke rising from the sept, stripped of his wife and his moral compass, enacts the final, terrible fulfilment of Maggy the Frog’s prophecy. In a moment of devastating simplicity, he removes his crown and steps from a window of the Red Keep. Cersei’s reaction—a brief, stunned grief that quickly hardens into resolve—underscores her transformation. The child who was the foundational justification for all her earlier machinations is gone, leaving only the raw will to power. Her coronation, witnessed by a horrified, freshly returned Jaime Lannister, is a stark, silent affair. Clad in black leather, she seizes the Iron Throne, no longer a queen regent but a queen in her own right. This closing of her emotional humanity effectively simplifies the board: Cersei, having decapitated the Tyrell alliance and destroyed the Faith, stands alone as the series’ principal human antagonist, a monster of her own creation.

Elsewhere, the episode diligently executes its mop-up functions, with varying degrees of success. Arya Stark’s long-awaited vengeance on Walder Frey delivers a visceral fan satisfaction, paying off the trauma of the Red Wedding. The reveal of the ‘meat pie’ as containing the remains of Walder’s sons, followed by Arya’s cold unveiling and throat-slitting, is undeniably potent. Yet, the Shakespearean extremity of the cannibalistic pastry, a direct borrow from Titus Andronicus, feels like a melodramatic overkill in a series that once derived its power from more grounded, political brutality. It prioritises grotesque poetic justice over the gritty realism that previously characterised the show’s violence.

The narrative tidying continues north. At Winterfell, the cost of victory is acknowledged as Melisandre, confronted by a grieving Ser Davos, admits her role in Princess Shireen’s burning. Jon Snow’s justice—exile under threat of death—feels appropriately stern, casting the Red Woman out into the snow. More significant is the political manoeuvring. Petyr Baelish’s offer to Sansa, envisioning them as partners on the Iron Throne, is met with a cool, inscrutable disdain that signals her hard-won wisdom. Instead, the Northern lords, rallying behind Lyanna Mormont’s electrifying speech, proclaim Jon Snow the ‘King in the North,’ a moment of rousing, if somewhat simplistic, triumphalism that solidifies a new power bloc.

The episode’s most consequential piece of narrative housekeeping, however, is reserved for Bran Stark. Delivered to the Wall by his undead uncle Benjen, Bran’s final vision at the weirwood tree unveils the saga’s central mystery. The flashback to the Tower of Joy is recontextualised: Lyanna Stark (Aisling Franciosi) is not a victim but a willing partner to Rhaegar Targaryen, dying in a bed of blood from childbirth. Her plea to Ned Stark lands with the force of a revelation. It retroactively transforms Ned Stark’s honourable life into a lifelong act of protective deceit and re-frames Jon Snow not as a bastard, but as the legitimate heir to two dynasties. This is the episode’s most successful piece of ‘mop-up,’ providing profound emotional and thematic payoff without resorting to spectacle.

Other threads are tied with less finesse. Samwell Tarly’s arrival at the Citadel offers a moment of whimsical bureaucratic satire but feels like a narrative placeholder. The scene in Dorne, where Olenna Tyrell allies with Ellaria Sand, is notably weakened by the jarring presence of Varys. The Master of Whisperers, supposedly in Meereen, appears in Dorne without any logical explanation for his transcontinental travel, an egregious example of the ‘teleportation’ problem that began to plague the series as geographic realism was sacrificed for plotting convenience. This issue is compounded minutes later when Varys is shown back aboard Daenerys’s fleet, a glaring continuity error that undermines the show’s previously careful attention to travel and time.

The finale concludes by setting the stage for the endgame. In Meereen, Daenerys painfully severs ties with Daario Naharis, leaving him behind as a garrison commander—a decision grounded in political pragmatism, however cold. The episode’s closing images are undeniably magnificent: a vast armada cutting through the waves, dragons soaring overhead, with Daenerys, Tyrion, and her combined forces of Unsullied and Dothraki finally turning west. It is a long-promised visual spectacle, a teaser of the climactic conflicts to come.

Yet, herein lies the central critique of Winds of Winter and, by extension, the trajectory it cemented for the series. If the aim was to provide an event more shocking and destructive than the Red Wedding, it unquestionably succeeded. The Sept explosion is television of a rare, audacious scale. However, in its relentless drive to simplify, the episode accelerates the show’s decline from a complex political tapestry into a more conventional, bipolar conflict. By the closing credits, the chessboard has been violently cleared. The nuanced, multi-faction struggle for the Iron Throne is reduced to a rather predictable contest between two women: one with dragons and a moral claim, the other with ruthless cunning and a fortified position. The rich ambiguity, the sense of countless competing agendas, is sacrificed for a cleaner, more cinematic showdown.

In the end, The Winds of Winter is a brilliantly executed piece of television spectacle and a ruthlessly efficient narrative engine. It delivers catharsis, revelation, and awe in ample measure. However, its very efficiency exposes the creative trade-offs at the heart of the show’s later seasons. The meticulous, cause-and-effect logic of earlier years gives way to moments of breathtaking but often contrived spectacle. Complex antagonists are physically eliminated en masse, and geographical realities are elasticated to serve the plot. The episode is a formidable peak in the series’ broadcast history. Yet, its shadow falls across the seasons that follow, revealing a narrative that, having burned away so much of its own intricate groundwork in one glorious, green flame, was left with a simpler, and ultimately less nourishing, story to tell.

RATING: 6/10 (++)

==

Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo
Substack https://draxster.substack.com

LeoDex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e

BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9