Philip K Dick's Electric Dreams - Impossible Planet review
Impossible Planet opens with an astonishing vista of a purple super nova, and extends what would be a normal visit to a place like an aquarium or museum to the cosmos. Only, the capitalism of the historical institute is progressed to a natural conclusion. Nothing is sacred. Everywhere can be a tourist attraction, for the right price. This is a story that shows a distant future of space tourism.
A time in the future where the universe is no longer a mystery and has been entirely chartered by humanity. Where space travel is an absolute commodity. As the story of Impossible Planet opens, it is a Friday afternoon, and two men are eager to knock off from their week of enhancing and exploiting the tourist experience, when there's a knock at their kiosk door.
It is an old woman who wants to go Earth. A place that hasn't been inhabited for hundreds of years, and is now very out the way. She offers a princely sum - what amounts to five years wages for each of the men, for the pleasure of seeing the planet - and off they go - the woman, the two men, and the woman's robot companion.
But not everything, and not everyone are what they seem on the surface. What follows is a suspenseful story with a "Who knows what they know and who doesn't know what they do know" full of gentle intrigue and the associated high stakes risk of discovery.
Impossible Planet is a story about how truth may just be more than what we simply observe, and how what we are told by others may just form enough truth. At least, for a fleeting moment in our existence. Who am I to question the zoo keeper who tells me of the behavioural patterns of the animals they steward? Or to use another example - if I know nothing about the way a car works - should I trust the mechanic's "truth", or seek to validate?
Or, on the case of this particular story - if someone tells me that my dream is within reach, and it is something that is possible, even though I may harbour suspicions or concerns of my own, could I not just close my own eyes and believe? If a lie makes you feel good, is it better than the truth?
This story is probably not intended to be a psychological horror, but it very can be interpreted as such - the horrors of ageing (where people lose their senses, but not their minds - a role in which the woman's robot companion acts as a kind of guardian) has strong lessons. That we should respect those who have come before, but if we are to cross the boundary from ambition to exploitation, or dream to nightmare - then we should definitely approach the fundamental truths of our place, and our responsibility to it - with integrity, not with a lie that makes someone else feel good.
But drama and lies do make the best stories, and this is easily one of them. Well produced, well acted, and incredibly detailed sets. I very much enjoyed Impossible Planet.
Phip K. Dick was truely a genius. The whole anthology is quite superb. Not too much action, but really uncomfortable questions asked.
I love those uncomfortable questions. It is why I love speculative fiction so much! :)
That first image reminds me of the casino (Canto Bight) in Star Wars Rogue One.
Never heard of this show before, thanks for the review.
And I have never seen Rogue One, but when I got a mystery box of science fiction books from the library the other week, an "extended version" novel of Rogue One was included. :D It will go on the "Read it eventually" pile.
Small world! I didn't love Rogue One, but it is a popular movie. Read it eventually = never read 😆
Just looked and it's actually from The Last Jedi, not Rogue One 🤷♂
Anyway, here is a screenshot I found, it has a similar futurist look and the red coloring.
Oh, I'll read it, even if that just gives me the opportunity to leave a scathing review (or I might be surprised).
This sort of concept Art is always so cool to see. It even looks like the Casino from Bablyon 5. I won't talk about that too deeply, I'm currently watching 2 or 3 episodes a week with a friend who has never seen it, and I'm LOVING the experience of watching the show, and the sense of "wow" and "holy shit" that the show is brining to someone who's never seen it.
Philip K. Dick was afflicted with the consequences of too much understanding, that eventually overwhelmed his reason and caused derangement in his interactions. He did write some incredible stories, and I have much enjoyed them.
It is impossible for the universe to be only what I can perceive of it, as I am a very infinitesimal speck of goo without much capability to perceive the majority of the universe. There is more to what we look at than we see.
Thanks!
Your reply is upvoted by @topcomment; a manual curation service that rewards meaningful and engaging comments.
More Info - Support us! - Reports - Discord Channel
I often wish I was more oblivious. I have nowhere near the same level of understanding as any of these fine authors.
Ted Chiang is one that is exceptional - if you've not read his collections of short stories, they are what I aspire to as an author of fiction, when I write it.
If I can achieve 10%, or even single digit percentages of the greatness of either of these writers, I will absolutely be overjoyed.
The closest I've ever come, I think, is my story, "Atomic Orgins".
I need to re-watch the entire run again. I don't remember this one...
I am very much enjoying these. Each one is a treat.
!PIMP