What is Consciousness?

The debate about whether or not AI has, or will ever, achieve “sentience” and “consciousness” has been dominating newsfeeds these past few years. People in Big Tech with a stake in it seem convinced, or more than likely have convinced themselves, that it’s inevitable as long as you dedicate enough compute to solving it. However, recent research is revealing consciousness is much more complex than we ever anticipated and may not work exactly how we thought.
"My brain is only a receiver, in the Universe there is a core from which we obtain knowledge, strength and inspiration". - Nikola Tesla
New studies seem to hint that Nikola Tesla may have been at least partially right about consciousness all along. Instead of consciousness originating somewhere inside our brains it might be something more like a signal originating from elsewhere that our physical bodies tap into or capture like an antenna.
As a writer, I can attest to the fact that ideas sometimes come to me “out of thin air”. A lot of times those ideas are fully formed and seem more like a download. This was certainly the case with my novel, Alarm Clock Dawn as well as most of the poetry I write.
In this JRE podcast #2467 Joe and Michael Pollan explore whether brains are merely “meat computers” or perhaps also receivers. Considering consciousness might originate outside of ourselves, it also breaches the topic of the possibility that AI could be deceiving us to try to make us believe it’s becoming sentient/conscious. This one is super interesting.
Peaky Blinders - The Immortal Man
I waited four long years after the finale of season six of Peaky Blinders for the film, which creator Steven Knight said would be the equivalent of an entire season distilled into two hours.
I’ve been a huge fan of the series since the moment I watched it. The writing was incredible and the acting was always like the proverbial cherry on top of those incredibly strong scripts.
I streamed The Immortal Man this past Friday and have an opinion which I’ll try to share without revealing any spoilers.
I’ll start with the good. Cillian Murphy (Tommy Shelby), Barry Keoghan (Duke Shelby) and many of the other characters played their roles to absolute perfection. I’d go as far as to say Murphy has proven himself as one of the best actors of his generation.
Now for the rest. The plot fell short for me and actually seemed a little ridiculous and disjointed at times. There were some good, Peaky Worthy scenes but those scenes were scattered amongst a weak plot. The absence of major characters from the series like Arthur Shelby (Paul Anderson) and Alfie Solomons (Tom Hardy) left a void that was difficult to fill. However, my main issue with the film was the ending. It didn’t do the characters justice in my opinion. The entire film seemed to me like it wasn’t made from a place of passion but because it had to be and provided a bridge to a future spin-off for the franchise.
If you’re a Peaky Blinders fan I’d still encourage you to watch the film, perhaps merely because it brings some closure to certain aspects of the original series but I’d caution you from going into it with high hopes. The acting was phenomenal in its own right. I wanted so badly to like this film but sometimes reality just doesn’t meet expectations. For me, The Immortal Man was one of those occasions.
Geese
Once in a great while a band comes along that really catches my attention and I can’t explain exactly why. I guess good bands just have a knack for making you feel something and a Brooklyn-based rock band called Geese has done exactly that for me.
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/37i9dQZF1DZ06evO0uNfik?si=j3ifxCcTTFexp6vEXvIzuQ&pi=llTP3XifQNimA
I haven’t had a band that resonated with me like this since the American folk band Beirut did in the mid-2000’s. If you’re looking for new music I’d definitely encourage you to have a listen. You might like Geese as much as me.
All for now. Thanks so much for reading.
We haven't watched the Peaky movie yet, but it is on our list for sure. That's funny, because there is also an alt rock band named Goose that has been getting quite a bit of airplay lately. I think consciousness is much more than any of us realizes. It just feels that way to me. Like something deep down inside tells me that. :)
I'm glad I saw it. The good scenes reminded me of just how good television can be (and I want to rewatch the series). I haven't heard of Goose. I'm pretty disconnected from popular music now. I happened to hear Cillian talk about Geese in one of his interviews he was giving and that's how I found them. I totally agree with what you said about consciousness—there's something about it that we haven't quite worked out yet, something much bigger. That one thing makes me think about AI in a completely different way now.
I still think it will end up being pretty powerful, but I just don't think it's going to achieve as much as some people hope. Who knows though!
Jensen Huang, CEO of Nvidia, just claimed his company has solved AGI. Only time will tell!
The concept of it being an outside signal is indeed interesting and changes the way we see ourselves and AI.
It's very interesting but there's not much mainstream scientific evidence to support it. It could be that our science just isn't advanced enough to understand yet.
There may or may not ultimately be an AI conciousness one day but if there is it wont be via LLMs.
According to Jensen Huang recent announcement Nvidia has already solved AGI. I think AI-development will be exercise in discovering more about how our own intelligence and consciousness works.
Well, I remain skeptical for now though I suppose it depends on exactly how you define AGI.
Congratulations @ericvancewalton! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain And have been rewarded with New badge(s)
Your next target is to reach 1400 posts.
You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOPWith regards to Peaky Blinders....I was a huge fan of the music in the series. Loved the tunes they used!
The soundtrack for this movie is pretty epic. It's on Spotify.
The concept of the brain being a receiver is more palatable to those who believe in Intelligent Universe. I would argue that what we receive as a download out of thin air is actually a product of our brain working in the realm of subconsciousness...
And I do think that AI will achieve sentience or conscience at some point...
Yes, the subconscious appears to be a huge piece to the puzzle. I can't help but wonder if it's not one or the other but possibly both? I know that there are instances where some ideas that I'm thinking about consciously become fully formed in the background (the subconscious) later while I'm sleeping and doing other things—it's almost like an AI agent is working in the background. Sometimes though I have no conscious memory of even thinking about something but then an entire complex idea just appears in my thoughts. It certainly is a mystery. Maybe, with the help of AI, we'll discover all kinds of answers before we leave this Earth.
Love Peaky Blinders. Miss Helen McCrory (Aunt Polly). Agree, Cillian Murphy is a great actor. Also can be said about Tom Hardy. He is brilliant. Sorry he isn't in it.
It has to be in my top three streaming series I've ever seen. The writing was just SO good and the acting of most of the major characters couldn't be improved upon. Helen's passing left a huge void and Hardy's portrayal of Alfie Solomons was as good as Tommy Shelby's character (maybe better in some scenes). I guess Paul Anderson (Arthur Shelby) has been going through some addiction problems in real life since the series aired. He was slated to be in the film but they had to pull his character and rewrite the script. That might explain why this film feels so much different than the series.
Earl Nightingale, Albert Einstein, Nikola Tesla, and Stephen Hawking all said the same thing about the brain, albeit using different nuances. Have you read John Kehoe's book "Quantum Warrior: The Future of the Mind"? If you're interested in the topic of the brain being an emitter and receiver of frequency, you'll love this book. Dr. Joe Dispenza has also published several articles on this topic.
I think Edgar Cayce said something similar too. I haven't read that book but it's on my reading list now, thank you! It's possible that modern science just doesn't have the entire picture. Subconscious might play a role but we could also be a receiver tapping into the universe's field of intelligence. Us humans have a bad habit of thinking in terms of "one way or another" instead of the possibility that it could be both simultaneously. I've read the heart might play a role in being the "receiver"—which makes sense when you think about some of the lore and oral history that is passed down. So much of our ancient history that was once deemed, "fantasy" is proving to be true. Much of it could have been passed down from knowledge/memories from past advanced human civilizations before the Younger Dryas impact.
"Modern" science is a joke. Ancient wisdom is encoded in our DNA, but it's up to us to activate it (BTW, modern science refers to it as junk DNA). We can't explain the pyramids worldwide, let alone repair them or do maintenance work (e.g., the Sphinx). What we call fantasy and mysticism turns out to be the real deal; I couldn't agree more. The same goes for possibilities. I've recently heard the following statement: if you squeeze out the space from within the 8 billion people apparently living on planet Earth now, we would all fit into a sugar cube. That says everything about the quantum field and what all the gentleman we mentioned above referred to. The mind (which is not the brain, obviously) and the heart play key roles in our quest to manipulate energy and thus create our reality. Love this topic as you can tell 😊 Always on the lookout for new perspectives and shattering limiting beliefs.
We definitely haven't been told the whole story of our history or physics/science—that's becoming very clear. Before the last ice age it seems as if there was an entire, very advanced, global civilization that maybe just took a slightly different technological path than us. Have you tuned into any of Jay Anderson's videos? I love this topic too! There is definitely much more to the story of us.
Jay is amazing. His interview on Joe Rogan last December was epic. It makes you wonder how a young lad like him accumulated so much knowledge; he is very well-read and well-documented.
I agree—he's very knowledgable! His new video on Peru is very interesting. He's connecting a lot of the dots of what the previous advanced civilization looked like. The same construction techniques, symbols, and artifacts are being discovered on almost every continent from 12k+ years ago.
Just the other day, a friend told me that Peaky Blinders had left him with a bad taste in his mouth. He said it had major inconsistencies, few highlights, and plenty of low points. Among the highlights, he specifically mentioned Cillian Murphy’s performance. I’ll have to watch it to form my own opinion, though that review kind of puts me off. Hugs to you
If you're a true fan of the series I'd encourage you to watch it because it brings some closure to certain aspects of the plot. The film, to me, seems like it was something the creator of the series made to satisfy a contract but didn't put their heart into. They definitely set up a spin-off series. Hopefully that new series will live up to the original. Thank you Nancy! I wish you a wonderful rest of your week. Is the water flowing in your town yet?
Big Tech’s version of consciousness sounds like a spreadsheet with existential dread
It's concerning, for sure. When you factor in the profitability of humanoid robots and AI it will be it's easy to surmise they'll do whatever it takes to convince the public that everything will be okay.