Film Review: The Patriot (2000)

If you ask AI chatbot to summarise plot of the generic Yugoslav Partisan film the most likely answer would be something like this. The protagonist, played by Ljubiša Samardžić, is widower and a war veteran, who lives peaceful, idyllic life in countryside with his seven children. This ends in 1941 when Hitler’s hordes occupy country. But the freedom-loving spirit within the people could not be suppressed, leading them to start uprising. Our protagonist, despite being encouraged by his friend, political commissar (played by Marko Nikolić), to use his martial skills to serve the insurgents, believes that Germans are a great power and opposing them would be futile. His barely adult son (played by Dragan Bjelogrlić), however, has different ideas and, unlike his father, takes up arms without hesitation. Initially, poorly armed and inexperienced rebels have little success against German forces equipped with artillery, aircraft, and tanks. After one such defeat, the injured son finds refuge at his father's estate. This will lead our hero to encounter a Nazi penal expedition led by a sadistic SS colonel (played by Radko Polič). Upon capturing and sentencing his rebel son to execution, the SS officer kills one of his sons, burns down their property, and drives away their livestock. Finally, this once peaceful widower decides to utilize his rich combat experience – after killing a German patrol and freeing his son, he sends the rest of his family into hiding with his former sister-in-law (played by Milena Dravić), who has feelings for him, while joining the ranks of the insurgents himself. Aware that fighting openly against the Germans is hopeless, he quickly organizes a guerrilla unit using “hit and run” strategy, inflicting heavy losses upon the Germans. Even Wehrmacht general (played by Peter Carsten), who sees himself as a chivalrous old school soldier, reluctantly approves unconventional and bloody counterinsurgency methods employed by his SS subordinate. Over time, the guerrilla unit becomes so strong that it attracts the support of a British allies who send liaison officer (played by Relja Bašić) to coordinate future cooperation. In the end, strengthened, enlightened, and inspired by Allied assistance, the insurgents decisively beat back the Germans and their domestic collaborators. Following the end of war our hero swears alongside his comrades that they won’t just rebuild what was destroyed and pillage, but also establish a new society based on social justice, brother and unity among the nations and ethnicities of Yugoslavia.

If someone asks what the above paragraph has to do with The Patriot, 2000 American historical epic directed by Roland Emmerich, the answer is very simple. The hypothetical and real film, despite some obvious differences in time and locations share exactly the same film. Furthermore, script by Robert Rodat, best kown for his work on Saving Private Ryan has more to do with the fiction of Yugoslav Partisan cinema than with actual historical truth of American Revolutionary War in South Carolina. Emmerich's film is actually most interesting as an example of lengths Hollywood was willing to take while trying to reconcile two major trends of late Clinton era - American self-righteousness and "political correctness."

The central character, Benjamin Martin (played by Mel Gibson), is loosely based on real historical figure Francis Marion, yet there isn't much connection due to good reasons. Marion is depicted in historical books as a sadistic monster who raped his own slaves and hunted Native Americans for sport. Similarly, the primary antagonist Colonel William Tavington (played by Jason Isaacs), modelled after British Colonel Banastre Tarleton, had emerged from the war with a reputation as a hero and spent the remainder of his life as a respected citizen of Liverpool and a long time member of British Parliament in Britain; however, in the film, Tavington is portrayed as a sadistic monster whose atrocious acts against American civilians would make even the Nazis uncomfortable. When we add scenes where women and African Americans in 18th Century American South appear to enjoy full equality, along with the absence of Native Americans, who mostly fought on the side of British, it becomes clear why this film can only be considered historically accurate only if we apply rather creative set of criteria.

On the other hand, just like with Gladiator, viewers who are not overly concerned with the complete historical authenticity will be satisfied. Those viewers who have long felt nostalgic for Yugoslav Partisan films would be even more pleased. Emmerich's films fully satisfies all the "rules" of films that were once proudly shown in cinema and television of former country. Hence, it is a fairly convincing hypothesis posited by Croatian film critic Jurica Pavičić in Slobodna Dalmacija newspaper that Emmerich, in his younger days, watched various Partisan films like Otpisani or Partisan Squadron. It wasn't difficult to replace the People's Liberation Struggle with the American Revolution, Germans with Redcoats, and MG42 machine guns and MP38 submachinegus with tomahawks and muskets. Emmerich has at least partially succeeded in this, and the casting of Mel Gibson of Braveheart fame has shown the actor’s inclination for such types of films. This is best seen in the action scenes, which are quite impressive not only for their brutality but also for faithfully reconstructing 18th Century tactics (when the speed and range of firearms necessitated the use of so-called line tactics in set piece battles).

Unfortunately, Emmerich's film falls short in many aspects when compared to Braveheart. While Gibson's film featured a charismatic villain, here we have cartoonish one-dimensional characters like Colonel Tavington and Lord Cornwallis, and this doesn't improve when played by talented British actors like Isaacs and Tom Wilkinson. Other supporting roles aren't any better either – Chris Klein, Cooper, and Joely Richardson merely work their parts, burdened with clunky dialogue. The younger protagonists fare even worse – the handsome Australian actor Heath Ledger in the role of Martin's son serves as a replacement for Leonarodo DiCaprio because someone needed to draw teenage girls to cinema, while his partner Lisa Brenner is simply awful. Emmerich, fortunately, possesses a sense of rhythm, so the sentimentally cheesy and predictable segments involving the private lives of characters between battles don't last too long. Patriot can be praised for its excellent cinematography by Caleb Deschanel, which greatly contributes to the beauty of the landscapes of South Carolina and the 18th Century costumes. Conversely, for the first time in a long time, legendary composer John Williams completely missed the mark. His score reduces itself to endless repetition that sometimes fails to distinguish itself from the late work of his hyper-productive colleague Ennio Morricone.

At the end of the day, Patriot is a film that will entertain you if you don't take it too seriously, and two and half hours in front of screen won't feel wasted. The author of this review, on the other hand, can’t escape impression that Ljubiša Samardžić armed with MG42 used to show far more charm and effectiveness than Mel Gibson armed with tomahawk.

RATING: 6/10 (++)

Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo

InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Unstoppable Domains: https://unstoppabledomains.com/?ref=3fc23fRc42c1b417
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax y
Bitcoin Lightning HIVE donations: https://v4v.app/v1/lnurlp/qrcode/drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e

BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7

Posted using CineTV